As parents, we all want our children to feel safe, understood, and valued in every environment they encounter - whether it’s at school, church, or a childcare setting. For children with a profile like my daughter’s, which I prefer to call “Persuasive Desire for Autonomy” (PDA), these environments can sometimes present unique challenges. It’s essential for teachers and caregivers to recognize that these children aren’t being defiant or difficult—they’re simply navigating the world in a way that makes sense to them.
Understanding PDA: It’s About Autonomy, Not Defiance
PDA, commonly referred to as Pathological Demand Avoidance, is often misunderstood. Kids with this profile have a strong need for autonomy and can feel extremely anxious or overwhelmed when they perceive demands being placed on them. This isn’t about being spoiled, stubborn, or defiant - it’s about managing a deep-seated need for control in a world that often feels unpredictable and overwhelming.
When my daughter chooses to play alone in the corner with a toy, she’s not being antisocial or difficult - she’s regulating herself in a way that feels safe and comfortable. Forcing her to share or participate in group activities can lead to anxiety or even shutdowns, not because she’s unwilling to engage, but because the demand itself feels like too much.
How Childcare Workers and Teachers Can Support Children with PDA
- Respect Their Need for Autonomy:
- What It Means: Allow children with PDA to have control over their environment and activities whenever possible.
- How to Do It: Offer choices instead of making demands. For example, instead of saying, “You need to join the group activity now,” try, “Would you like to play with the blocks or read a book?” Giving options helps these children feel more in control and less pressured.
-
Create a Safe Space for Independent Play:
- What It Means: Understand that some children genuinely thrive in solitary play. It’s their way of processing the world and feeling secure.
- How to Do It: Provide a designated area where a child can retreat and engage in solo activities without being disturbed. This space should be respected by both adults and peers, allowing the child to return to group activities when they feel ready.
-
Avoid Labels and Assumptions:
- What It Means: Recognize that being an only child, blaming the parenting or any other aspect of a child’s background, doesn’t define their social behavior.
- How to Do It: Instead of attributing a child’s need for solitude to being an only child, the parenting or another characteristic, take the time to understand their individual needs and preferences. Every child is different, and their reasons for seeking independence can vary widely.
-
Focus on Connection Over Compliance:
- What It Means: Prioritize building a trusting relationship with the child over enforcing rules or expectations.
- How to Do It: Spend time getting to know the child’s interests and preferred activities. Engage with them on their terms, showing that you’re a supportive presence rather than someone who imposes demands.
-
Be Flexible and Patient:
- What It Means: Children with PDA might need more time to transition between activities or might resist certain tasks altogether.
- How to Do It: Instead of pushing for immediate compliance, give the child space to come around in their own time. Use gentle encouragement and offer help without pressure. Flexibility is key to helping them feel secure.
Why This Matters
Understanding and supporting children with PDA in educational and childcare settings is crucial for their emotional well-being. These children aren’t trying to be difficult - they’re trying to navigate a world that often feels overwhelming. By respecting their need for autonomy, creating safe spaces for independent play, and building connections based on trust and understanding, teachers and caregivers can nurture these children in ways that honor their unique needs.
Let’s move away from discipline that punishes differences and towards a model of care that celebrates and supports every child’s individuality. After all, isn’t that what nurturing truly means?
